Overview

Five Spur Steakhouse, nestled in the heart of Cherryville, North Carolina, offers a refined take on classic American dining. Located at 115 E Main St, this steakhouse combines a welcoming atmosphere with a menu focused on hearty, well-executed dishes that appeal to both families and steak enthusiasts.

At Five Spur Steakhouse, the stars of the menu are unquestionably their expertly prepared steaks—from New York Strip to Ribeye—each arriving at the table perfectly cooked and often accompanied by flavorful compound butters. But the excellence doesn’t stop there; the menu stretches to include thoughtfully crafted chicken entrees like Chef Steve's renowned Chicken Marsala and indulgent pasta options such as Lobster Ravioli that add a touch of elegant variety to the meat-centric offerings.

The restaurant space strikes a balance between polished and inviting. Whether you’re enjoying a dinner out with family after church or a quiet night with friends, the atmosphere fosters relaxation without feeling rushed. Multiple customer accounts praise attentive service, highlighting servers like Makenzie and Melissa whose genuine care adds warmth to the dining experience. The thoughtful pacing of meals allows guests moments to linger over conversation, creating a memorable night rather than a hurried meal.

Portion sizes here satisfy without overwhelming, catering well to those seeking both generous servings and quality. For starters, the cheese curds paired with homemade marinara and optional ranch dips set an excellent tone, while sides like mushroom risotto and homemade mac and cheese receive frequent praise. Desserts, especially the cheesecake selections available by the slice, provide a perfect finishing touch and a tempting takeaway option.

Five Spur Steakhouse clearly understands its audience: diners who appreciate a high-quality steakhouse experience without the stiff formality. Its location in downtown Cherryville makes it an accessible destination for locals and visitors alike, delivering a dependable culinary experience marked by flavor, service, and comfortable surroundings. This spot stands out not just for the food, but for the care evident in every aspect—from the greeting at the door to the last bite of dessert.

For anyone craving authentic American steakhouse fare in a setting that feels both special and approachable, Five Spur Steakhouse is worth the visit. Whether seeking a lively family outing or a quiet celebration, the restaurant’s blend of classic dishes and attentive hospitality ensures guests leave eager to return.


Amenities & Services

Popular for
Lunch
Dinner
Solo dining
Offerings
Coffee
Comfort food
Food
Quick bite
Small plates
Atmosphere
Casual
Cosy
Trendy

What Customers Say

Robin Bridges
Dec 11,2025
5/5
The food was amazing our server Makenzie was amazing. She was truly genuine. Always smiling and checking in with our table. You did right when you hired her. 100%. Professional. Great service. We made reservations. The food was not rushed like most places. After our salads came we had a few minutes before the meal came to just talk. It was a sisters night out. Then they bring a dessert tray for you to check out. Definitely get some to go. You will be to full to eat it there. Lol
Dennis W
Dec 11,2025
5/5
Great steak dinner in downtown Cherryville!! Wonderful experience all around. The NY Strip and Ribeye were both perfectly prepared. Finished with a yummy compound butter. Mushroom risotto was especially good. We'll be back!
Heather Bass
Dec 11,2025
5/5
I usually start a review off with how nice the restaurant looked but I have to start with the food! My husband ordered Steve's chi Ken and said it was the best he has EVER had. I ordered prime rib and it was out of this world good. Service was great and the restaurant looked amazing.
Katelyn Ford
Dec 11,2025
5/5
Great service, large portions, and a tasty menu! Our family made a reservation for after church. We arrived a few minutes early & the host promptly greeted us and sat us at our table. To start, we ordered the cheese curds (not pictured) which were served with a homemade marinara sauce — we opted to add a ranch for dipping as well. Our server was very attentive and kept our glasses full as we ate our salads and while we waited for our main course. Our table all ordered different items and we were all impressed by the flavor and portion sizes. Before bringing the check, our server, Melissa, offered us dessert. They had a variety of cheesecakes that were sold by the slice that would be great to take to-go to enjoy later in the evening. Overall, we had a wonderful experience and it was definitely worth the 30 minute drive. We will be back very soon! Pictured: -Country fried steak with mashed potatoes and green beans -Chicken Parmesan pasta -Crab cakes and broccolini
Ashley D
Dec 11,2025
5/5
Finally got to try this restaurant on a Wednesday evening . My coworker and I had a reservation , but we didn’t need it . ( seems like you do need reservations Friday and Saturday .) The inside looks great , they did a great job with the building . We both had sirloins, which were cooked perfect and delicious . Mac and cheese and potatoes were amazing . They have a large variety of cheesecakes - we both took some to go (they were amazing by the way ). Also was impressed by how affordable it was . For a high quality meal the price really couldn’t be beat . We will definitely be back!
Patrick O'Leary
Dec 11,2025
5/5
Incredible 5 star experience at Five Spur Steakhouse for our first visit. 2 of us had the 22 oz bone-in ribeye, one had the filet and one had the pork chop. All cooked to perfection and great portions. Pricing is very fair. The owners spoke to all tables. Our waitress Madison did a fantastic job. The restored 1930 building is beautiful. Finished with some glasses of spectacular "Elmer T. Lee" Single Barrel Bourbon from the bar.
Adrienne Lanza
Dec 11,2025
5/5
Beautifully restored building, extremely friendly and attentive staff. We both had the ribeye and it was PHENOMENAL, cooked to order and seasoned beautifully! 5 Spur Steakhouse is a welcomed and much needed fine dining experience in Cherryville at a reasonable price for the quality. Would recommend 10 out of 10, already looking forward to our next visit!
Catherine Smith
Dec 11,2025
5/5
GIVE THIS PLACE A TRY! It’s worth it! I surprised my husband for his birthday and took him somewhere new and I’m so glad we did! I had met the owners wife a couple months ago and she told me about this place! At first glance, this restaurant is gorgeous! From the hardwood floors, to the saddles, to the rustic Christmas tree! The welcoming staff was very friendly and seated us within 7 minutes of our reservation time! We ordered the calamari as our appetizer and it was great! It wasn’t the tiny little calamari you get at Olive Garden, it was delicious. My husband ordered the filet with broccolini and cheesy potato au gratin; the steak was very well seasoned and super tender; the sides were fantastic as well! I ordered crab cakes with mashed potatoes and gravy and asparagus. Now the shocker for me was the remoulade!!!! I have NEVER found a remoulade that I actually enjoyed but this was out of this world good and I actually used it on my crab cakes! Our waitress was Allie and she was the sweetest! She was very attentive and constantly made sure we were doing well. She also had a helper since it was his first day, Brandon, but you could tell he was not new to the industry! He was very attentive and checked on us regularly as well! The conversation with them both made me feel right at home! This restaurant is the true meaning of casual dining! I did NOT feel rushed! Our meal came out about 30 minutes after our appetizer and that was fantastic! I hate when my meal comes out while I’m still eating my appetizer! And then Allie and Brandon offered us dessert which is made locally at a bakery and it was delicious as well! Recommend 10/10

Leave a Review

Location

Opening Hours

Monday Closed
Tuesday Closed
Wednesday 04:00 PM - 09:00 PM
Thursday 04:00 PM - 09:00 PM
Friday 04:00 PM - 10:00 PM
Saturday 03:00 PM - 10:00 PM
Sunday 11:00 AM - 03:00 PM
Top Picks for You

More American Restaurants in Cherryville, North Carolina, USA

Handpicked spots for food lovers. Your next favorite meal awaits!